By continuing your visit to this site, you accept the use of cookies. They ensure the proper functioning of our services, analytics tools and display of relevant ads. Learn more about cookies and control them

Not yet registered? Create a OverBlog!

Create my blog

A guide to wine ratings

Robert M. Parker, Jr. is credited for the 100-point wine rating system. Critics bemoan that the system is so influential that wine producers make wines which match reviewers' specific preferences.

Robert Parker on wine

Love and wine Parker’s interest in wine began in 1967, on a Christmas vacation visiting his high school sweetheart in Alsace, France where she studied at University of Strasbourg. She had written him irregularly and Parker worried that some suave Frenchman might sweep her off her feet. They’ve been married now for 37 years, so Parker’s trip was a success on many levels. Let the tasting begin Back at college, Parker formed a wine-tasting group of fellow students. As they started rating wines, they soon observed that price and reputation are no guarantee for the best wines. After college and law school, Parker began a wine newsletter that eventuated into The Wine Advocate.

Wine by the numbers

The 100-point scale In the mid-1970s, Parker popularised his 100-point rating scale. Most wine magazines essentially use the same system, including The Wine Spectator and Wine Enthusiast. What do the numbers mean? One or more reviewers taste the wine blindly: no labels, no price or winery information. Reviewers assign numeric ratings according to this criteria: 96-100 - Extraordinary, a classic wine of its variety. 90-95 - Outstanding, exceptional complexity and character. 80-89 - Barely above average to very good, wine with various degrees of flavour. 70-79 - Average, little distinction beyond being soundly made. 60-69 - Below average, drinkable, but containing noticeable deficiencies. 50-59 - Poor and unacceptable not recommended.

Beyond wine ratings

Linear scale Numeric ratings imply that wine's quality is one-dimensional. A number doesn't tell you if a Chardonnay is okay or the wine is drinkable now or needs cellaring for two years. Read beyond the number to see, if the reviewer tells what they liked about the wine. Robert Parker himself suggests reading tasting notes in addition to the rating. Wine rating is subjective Just like one’s taste in fiction, not everyone loves Stephen King, or “big” Cabernets. If you follow a particular reviewer enough to know that his or her taste in California Syrahs, for example, is similar to yours, their wine recommendations may be more reliable for you. Be aware that wine publications assign different reviewers to different wine regions. Wine Spectator, for instance, has three different reviewers for California wines. Someone else reviews Oregon, Washington and Australian wines. The limits of numeric ratings Gary Rivlin, in the International Herald Tribune, writes, “Ratings are quick judgments that a single individual renders early in the life of a bottle of wine that, once expressed numerically, magically transform the nebulous and subjective into the authoritative and objective.”

Same category articles Wines & Spirits

Tips for food and wine pairing

Tips for food and wine pairing

Pairing wine with food needn't be a daunting task. Some people will state that there are certain golden rules to doing this, but this isn't necessarily true. It is obvious that there are a few simple principles when deciding which wine goes with which food, but in the end, it is really a matter of taste. This article contains a few guidelines to make it easier to select a wine for a certain dish.
Where to buy kosher wine

Where to buy kosher wine

Made especially according to the religious law of Judaism, kosher wine is grape wine that adheres to Jewish dietary law. The most important element in its production is that only Jews who observe the Sabbath should be involved. In addition, everything used in the winemaking process must be kosher too. Kosher wine is becoming increasingly popular and two of the largest manufacturers are based in the US.
How to choose from Victoria Wine's selection

How to choose from Victoria Wine's selection

There are many things to consider when shopping in wine shops. After all, choosing the right wine can be a challenge. This article will tell you some of the things that you should think about when trying to choose a bottle of wine.
A buyer's guide to South African wines

A buyer's guide to South African wines

South Africa is the ninth largest wine-producing country in the world, and the country produces a wide range of wines. With this article, you can find out all that you need to know on South African wines.