Not yet registered? Create a OverBlog!

Create my blog

How democratic is the American Constitution in today's America?

The political theorist Robert Dahl has growing doubts about how democratic the American Constitution is. This article discusses his concerns that it does not guarantee political equality for all groups and individuals. The problem is that rich groups and people have more access to power than others do.

Dahl's doubts about U.S. democracy

Contradictory claims
When C.Mills declared that U.S.democracy was dominated by an elite, Dahl rebutted his claim, saying that instead it was polyarchic, meaning that there were several competing power bases rather than one.However, in recent years Dahl has become more pessimistic that the constitution can deliver genuine democracy in the political, social and cultural conditions that prevail in the America today.
Power as a tool solely for economic elites
Power seems to be disproportionately wielded by an economic and social elite. His concern is that while the founding fathers acted in good will, they also acted in deep ignorance about the future, and were unaware of how much economic power can distort the equality guaranteed by the constitution. His concern is deepened by his inability to see any means of reforming this situation short of a constitutional collapse.

What is going wrong

Dahl establishes certain criteria by which a democracy should be measured. These are:
effective participation for all,
voting equality,
enlightened understanding,
control of the agenda and
inclusiveness. Greater control and access
He feels that the constitution cannot guarantee full compliance with all of these criteria. Equal participation is threatened, he believes, by the ability to wealthy individuals and groups to have greater access to legislators through professional lobbyists, which gives them control of the agenda to a greater degree than poorer people have.
Funding
Furthermore, presidential, congressional and senatorial candidates have to seek funding from rich groups and individuals to mount effective campaigns, giving such individuals an unequal influence on the agenda.
Education
Enlightened understanding may not always be equally distributed, as educational opportunities are greater for wealthy groups than for poorer ones, and because powerful groups control the media and select and distort information to suit their own agenda. Inequalities (influence, information, control of agendas)
The question is not whether the U.S. is a democratic society, as it clearly is one. Everyone enjoys equal rights and has the vote, and the legislature and president are elected by universal suffrage. However, Dahl's concern is with the inequalities in the distribution of influence and information, with rich and powerful people enjoying more than their fair share at the expense of poorer and marginalised people and groups. The U.S. Constitution, therefore, in Dahl's view, creates a flawed democracy

Same category articles History

Hanscom AFB: The facts

Hanscom afb: the facts

Hanscom air force base (afb) is a united states air force facility which is located close to the massachusetts national guard barracks. established in 1942, it was named after laurence g. hanscom, a local aviator and journalist who died in an accident the year before.
The archaeology of Noah and the flood

The archaeology of noah and the flood

The legend of noah's flood was developed out of flood legends current in the first millenium b.c, and was probably a conflation of different legends. some scholars think that the source of the legend may be the flooding of the black sea in 5,600, but others have speculated that the legend might have been based on floodings in mesopotamia.
Boris Johnson: biography

Boris johnson: biography

Alexander boris de pfeffel johnson is a british conservative politician, journalist and mayor of london since 2008.
Who has the top secret clearance in the UK?

Who has the top secret clearance in the uk?

Top secret clearance is the process of being vetted to view restricted or classified information. part of this top secret clearance involves a thorough background check of the individual. an individual who has undertaken a top secret clearance however, has to justify why he needs to see the information and provides valid reasons for doing so.